For brands selling in the US, the question is rarely whether to be on Amazon or Walmart. It is which one to put serious time and budget into first. Getting the order right can save months. This Amazon vs Walmart marketplace comparison covers what actually changes your decision.
The short answer
- Start with Amazon if you need volume fast, sell in a category with strong search demand, and can fund advertising from day one.
- Prioritise Walmart if your category is crowded on Amazon, your products suit value-focused shoppers, and you can meet Walmart’s operational standards.
- Run both once one channel is profitable and your inventory and listings are stable enough to replicate.
Audience and reach
Amazon has the larger marketplace audience and is where many shoppers start their product search. Walmart’s online audience overlaps with its huge physical store customer base and skews towards everyday, value-driven purchases. Think about where your buyer naturally shops, not just where the traffic is.
Competition
This is often the deciding factor. On Amazon, popular categories can have dozens of established sellers competing for the same keywords, which pushes up advertising costs. Walmart Marketplace generally has fewer sellers per category, so a well-optimised listing can gain visibility faster. The trade-off is lower total demand.
Getting approved
Amazon lets most businesses open a seller account and start listing quickly, as outlined on Amazon’s seller hub. Walmart Marketplace has an application and review process, with requirements around business registration, marketplace track record and operations. Check the current criteria on Walmart Marketplace before you plan a launch date, as eligibility rules change.
Fees
Both platforms charge a referral fee per sale that varies by category, plus fulfilment costs if you use their fulfilment networks (FBA on Amazon, WFS on Walmart). Amazon also has a monthly subscription for professional sellers. Rather than comparing headline percentages, build a per-unit margin sheet for your actual products on both platforms, including fulfilment, storage and expected return rates.
Advertising
Amazon Ads is more mature, with more ad formats, targeting options and third-party tools. Walmart Connect has grown quickly and cost per click is often lower in less competitive categories. Whichever you start with, keep a close eye on total advertising cost relative to total sales, not just campaign-level returns. We cover that in detail in why your Amazon ads look profitable but your account isn’t.
Operations and account health
Both marketplaces measure on-time shipping, cancellations and customer experience. Walmart is known for being strict on performance standards, so brands with unreliable inventory or slow fulfilment can struggle there. If your operations are still settling, Amazon FBA can take a lot of that load while you build processes.
A practical way to decide
- Search your top 10 keywords on both sites and note how many strong competitors appear
- Calculate per-unit margin for each platform with real fee and fulfilment numbers
- Check whether you meet Walmart’s current seller requirements
- Estimate the ad budget needed to reach page one on each
- Choose the channel where margin after ads is highest, then plan the second channel for 3 to 6 months later
Do not forget your own store
Marketplaces rent you customers. Your own Shopify or WordPress store lets you keep them, collect emails and build repeat purchases. Many of our clients use marketplaces for discovery and their own site for loyalty. See how we approach website design and development and marketplace growth and advertising together.
Not sure which marketplace fits your brand?
We manage Amazon, Walmart, Etsy, eBay and more for brands in India, the US and Canada. We will look at your category and margins and tell you honestly where to start.
